Wednesday, February 2, 2011

South Korea: Truth but no reconciliation

Published on : 2 February 2011 - 9:36am | By International Justice Tribune (IJT 121)


South Korea’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission in December concluded its historic exploration into the brutality of mass killing by both sides during the Korean War in an atmosphere of frustration and controversy.
By Don Kirk, Seoul
The commission, from its inception in 2005, uncovered the truth about the deaths of tens of thousands of civilians at the hands of South Korean police and soldiers and invading North Koreans. However, it failed in more than five years to bring reconciliation. One reason for this failure is that it ceased functioning before investigating all the reported massacres during the1950 – 1953 war.
“The past remains a political minefield in South Korea,” according to journalist and researcher Choe Sang-hun. “Digging into South Korea’s tumultuous recent history remains a sensitive and painful task riddled with controversy,” said Choe, who won a Pulitzer prize for his reporting on the massacre by US soldiers of South Koreans huddled under a bridge in the village of Nogunri in 1950.
“Pro-democracy activists who struggled against the past military dictators and took power under former presidents Kim Dae-jung and Roh Tae-woo saw the task of peeling back the long-running cover-up as a hallmark of their mandate,” he said. “But conservatives who took pride in defending the nation from communism saw these efforts as a leftist political maneuver to discredit their reputation.”
During liberal rule from 1998 to 2008, in which Kim and Roh served successive five-year presidential terms, Koreans had the chance to uncover what former commission member Kim Dong-choon called “the dark side of the Korean past.” Kim Dae-jung during his presidency encouraged the formation of the commission, formed as a government agency during Roh’s tenure.
The commission’s leadership from the outset was divided among standing commissioners representing liberal and conservative views, but conservatives dominated after the inauguration in February 2008 of Lee Myung-bak.
The commission’s deadline was April 2010, but the investigations were extended until June. Some commission workers stayed on until the end of 2010.
Kim Dong-choon, also a sociologist at Sung Kong Hoe University, believes the commission needed two more years to visit massacre sites that will probably never be excavated. The commission did exhume 13 sites, but “there are many more that we must study and research,” he said.
Kim said the legacy of suffering lives on among the families of victims. “They still have some economic and psychological difficulties. Some communities were totally disorganised.” As for why the commission’s activities were not extended, he points out that conservative officials “don’t want to make this kind of incident known to the Korean people and to other people.”
Estimates vary as to how many civilians were killed. Kim said that between 100,000 and 200,000 people died at the hands of South Korean police and soldiers as North Korean forces moved south in 1950. He believes the total killed by North Koreans was “less than half the number.”
Lee Young Jo, the commission’s last president, disagrees, estimating that South Korean and North Korean forces each killed about 150,000 civilians. Nor does he believe that the commission ended its work prematurely. He pointed out that the body’s mandate was to review petitions of families, and that it completed all 11,000 cases that it was asked to consider.
The courts ordered state apologies in many cases. In the most infamous one, in which eight people were hanged in April 1975 for a plot made up by the Korean intelligence service to form a revolutionary party, a court in January 2007 absolved them all, awarding $67 million to family members.
The investigation also revealed the failure of US officers to stop the executions of South Koreans, though some witnessed and reported what had happened. The US issued just one “regret,” which was for the slaughter of civilians at Nogunri, following a press report revealing the massacre in 1999.
Choe said it was a “disgrace to the South Korean political leaders and media” that the truth came out at so late, though he added that “the fact that South Korea has launched the commission and let it do what it has done, despite all its controversy” is proof that the situation in the country has improved since the era of dictatorship ended in 1987.
http://www.rnw.nl/international-justice/article/south-korea-truth-no-reconciliation

Nepal's human rights examination



 
 
DR DINESH BHATTARAI
The United Nations General Assembly Resolution A/60/251 also known as the founding resolution of the Human Rights Council (HRC) mandated it to ‘undertake a universal periodic review (UPR) based on objective and reliable information, of the fulfillment by each state of its human rights obligations and commitments in a manner which ensures universality of coverage and equal treatment with respect to all States.’ The HRC was established in 2006 in place of the Commission on Human Rights (CHR) which in words of the former UN Secretary General Kofi Annan reached ‘a point at which the Commission’s declining credibility has cast a shadow on the reputation of the United Nations system.’ 

UPR is an innovative mechanism based on three hours of ‘interactive dialogue and cooperation, with full involvement of the country concerned and with consideration given to its capacity building needs, such a mechanism shall complement and not duplicate the work of treaty bodies.’ This unique tool is a peer review mechanism for every country in four year periodicity, ‘assessing the implementation of international norms and treaties on ground.’ 

Nepal is among the 16 United Nations member states undergoing UPR – at the 10th session of UPR Working Group of the HRC that started from Jan 24 and will continue till Feb 4, 2011. Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Foreign Affairs Sujata Koirala formally introduced the National Report of Nepal on Jan 25. The report was prepared with extensive public consultations at various levels in the country. It outlines the achievements Nepal made after the success of the peaceful People’s Movement and discusses in candid manner the challenges and constraints that stand in way of realizing the human rights by the people. The problems that the country faces in the post-conflict situation are also outlined in the report. 

The Working Group of UPR of the Council assesses the performance of every member state of the United Nations, big and small, developed and developing and rich and poor. So far nine sessions of the Working Group on UPR have been held and 143 countries have been reviewed. Nepal is the 146th country to be reviewed. The first cycle of the UPR will complete later this year taking up the assessment of the human rights performance of the entire membership of the United Nations. The review is accessible to the general public through the HRC webcast.

UPR is based on three sets of information: 1. National Report from the government, 2. Information compiled by the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) from reports of the UN Agencies, Special Procedures and Treaty Bodies and 3. Information compiled by OHCHR from reports of NGOs, NHRIs and other stakeholders.

During the three hours interactive dialogue, member/observer states ask questions and make recommendations which form the cornerstone of the UPR process. Recommendations are expected to guide the state under review for the next four years. 
Nepali peace process grew out of their commitments to human rights, democratic pluralism and constitutionalism. Nepal is working hard to lay the essential foundation for institutionalizing these commitments. The road to democracy is irreversible, however slow, uneven, long and at times uncertain and arduous it may appear.

The assessment of the human rights situation in Nepal comes at a time when the country is making a democratic transition from absolute monarchy to democratic republic after over a decade-long armed conflict during which about 16,000 people were killed, 5,800 were disabled, 71,200 people were internally displaced, public infrastructures including the government buildings, schools, colleges, health posts, roads and bridges were destroyed. The impact of human cost, economic cost, social and psychological cost of conflict on the general public has been incalculable. 

The Comprehensive Peace Accord (CPA) of Nov 21, 2006 signed between the Government of Nepal and Communist Party of Nepal (Maoist) formally ended the armed conflict, paving the way for the establishment of the universally accepted concepts of fundamental human rights, multiparty competitive democratic system, supremacy of the people, adult franchise, periodic elections, rule of law, promotion and protection of human rights of people, full press freedom, constitutional checks and balances and independent judiciary based on democratic values and norms. The Interim Constitution of Nepal prepared through political consensus promulgated on Jan 15, 2007 by parliament is a comprehensive catalogue of fundamental rights incorporating the rights set forth in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights of the UN and the rights and obligations enshrined in the international human rights instruments to which Nepal is a party such as the 1966 International Covenants on Civil and Political Rights and on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. The protection and promotion of human rights remain at the center of the peace process. 

The election of Constituent Assembly (CA) on April 10, 2008 is a defining feature of the peace process. It established the supremacy of ballots over bullets. Out of 74 political parties registered with the Election Commission, 54 contested the CA elections and 25 of them have a representation in the CA, which stands as an epitome of the inclusiveness and proportionality. The peace process has brought the people to the center of governance from the periphery, exclusion, and disadvantaged zones. Representation of women and marginalized groups in the legislature parliament constitute 33.23 percent and 33.39 percent respectively. Government undertakings including the security forces are taking pro-active affirmative actions to recruit on a priority basis from among the marginalized/underrepresented communities to ensure inclusiveness and equity. They now participate in decisions that shape their destiny and the future of the country. 

The peace process has crossed several milestones. CA elections, declaration of the country as the federal democratic republic, release of minors and disqualified combatants from cantonments, and the formal handover on Jan 22 of the command and control of the Maoist combatants housed in the seven cantonments and 21 satellite cantonments to the constitutionally mandated Special Committee with the responsibilities of their supervision, integration and rehabilitation are the major milestones of the home grown peace process. Nepal’s peaceful transformation provides a rare example in the contemporary world history. 

Democracy in Nepal has entered into a new phase with human rights and inclusiveness at the center. Nepal is a party to different international human rights instruments and covenants. Government is committed to addressing the past injustices and future challenges as provided in the CPA and the Interim Constitution. The mechanisms for providing transitional justice have been submitted to the parliament for approval. Nepal´s independent judiciary has made landmark judgments in favor of human rights protection. Nepal was among the first least developed countries to establish the National Human Rights Commission. There are other institutions established to investigate abuse of power and improper conduct

CHALLENGES & CONSTRAINTS 

The government realizes that there is no room for complacency despite remarkable achievements made in the human rights situation since the end of the armed conflict. Nepal is in a transitional phase. Transition is an extremely difficult and highly sensitive period. Institutionalization of peace, social and economic transformation within the democratic framework, and the process of post-conflict reconstruction and rehabilitation and reconciliation are facing daunting institutional and humanitarian challenges. Various economic and social woes from the past and emerging challenges emanating from the global multiple crises including the economic and financial crises and climate change remain as growing threats to the enjoyment of human rights with far-reaching implications. 

Consensus building is a tough call in any post-conflict situation and Nepal is no exception. Nepal’s political parties of different ideologies are deeply engaged in forging unity, evolving consensus and concluding agreement on the broader national agendas in relation to political, economic, social transformation and development. Dialogue, cooperation and participation form the core of Nepali peace process. Nepal is facing multi-dimensional challenges of Himalayan proportions on multiple fronts. Lack of resources, capacity and physical, institutional and human rights infrastructures in the country remain as significant constraints in honoring its obligations to provide basic services to marginalized or vulnerable communities or groups. There is an urgent need to seriously address the root causes of conflict and democratic deficits rather than just treating the symptoms. 

LEARNING FROM THE PAST & LOOKING TO THE FUTURE

Nepal has come a long way in terms of peaceful resolution of armed conflict and political transformation within the overall framework of democratic polity. Nepali peace process, having emerged from a background of violence, and destruction has established the primacy of dialogue, understanding and need for democratic institutions to address the glaring challenges in the country without resorting to violence and use of arms in politics. The peace process has heralded a clear shift from violent activities toward peaceful means. The peace and democratic process has brought former foes together and made them realize that they need each other to resolve their differences in a peaceful manner for the country and the people who have made arduous struggles and unparalleled sacrifices time and again for a democratic pluralistic society that honors human rights in all circumstances. 

There have been formations of government and changes of governments on the basis of constitutional provisions in a peaceful manner. Political parties, irrespective of their ideological differences, listen to dissenting voices and recognize the need to solidify the democratic foundations by completing the task of writing a democratic constitution by the CA. The primacy of dialogue as a compromise seeking and deadlock breaking mechanism has been established and this needs to be concretely institutionalized as peaceful means to advance political objectives.

There is no denying that at this juncture of democratic transition, Nepal is confronting the severity of challenges, fragility of institutions, enormity of capacity constraints in the process of post-conflict reconstruction, rehabilitation and reconciliation to make the democratic process a success. The long and uphill tasks of institution building are better served by generating local legitimacy, local knowledge and local leadership. As we remain engaged in laying unshakeable and unassailable institutional framework for human rights and rule of law to address the democratic aspirations of our people, we look forward to a constructive interaction and contributions from the international community. Sustained solidarity and support will help democracy take roots, firmly institutionalize peace building efforts, create a web of national democratic institutions, make all concerned honor institutional norms in day to day work, and help make the socioeconomic transformation sustainable within the democratic framework leading to the enjoyment of all kinds of human rights by the Nepali people. 

The people of Nepal have set the highest standards in human rights through their arduous struggles and immense sacrifices. They have said NO to undemocratic and unconstitutional rule, and they have said NO to the violent path to political power. Nepali peace process grew out of their commitments to human rights, democratic pluralism and constitutionalism. Nepal is working hard to lay the essential foundation for institutionalizing these commitments. The road to democracy is irreversible, however slow, uneven, long and at times uncertain and arduous it may appear. Therein lies the secure, democratic and prosperous future of the country. As the visionary leader B P Koirala said in an interview to Theodore Jacqueney of Worldview way back in 1978, ‘If Nepal has to exist as a nation or develop as a nation, it must develop democratic institutions’. After a rollercoaster journey throughout its modern history and especially in the recent past, Nepal is firmly on the democratic path shown by the national leadership. 

Writer is Ambassador/Permanent Representative of Nepal to UN and International Organizations

dineshbhattarai1@gmail.com

http://myrepublica.com/portal/index.php?action=news_details&news_id=27572

Friday, January 28, 2011

Report: Japan Forced 30,000 Koreans to Work on Sakhalin

A government investigation has found that during the Japanese colonial rule of Korea, up to 30-thousand Koreans were forced into labor by Japan on Sakhalin, an island now belonging to Russia and that a third of them never returned.
The Truth Commission on Forced Mobilization under Japanese Imperialism said in a report on Tuesday that, while it was previously thought that around 43-thousand Korean people were taken to Sakhalin, considering that about 70-percent of Korea's population at the time was male, the figure is probably closer to 30-thousand.
Of all the cases examined by the commission on Sakhalin, in 34.3 percent of them involved a person who died or went missing there, a rate much higher than other regions where Japan used conscripted Korean labor.

JAN 28, 2011
 
Reporter : devin@arirang.co.kr

http://www.arirang.co.kr/News/News_View.asp?nseq=111985&code=Ne2&category=2

Thursday, January 27, 2011

NEPAL: Nepal urged to accept and implement UPR recommendations and end impunity


On Tuesday, Nepal's human rights record was reviewed for the first time under the United Nations (UN) Human Rights Council’s Universal Periodic Review (UPR). The UPR process was established by the UN General Assembly on 15 March 2006 through resolution 60/251 to "review the fulfilment by each State of its human rights obligations and commitments." The procedure assessed Nepal's compliance with its international obligations to protect and promote human rights.

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE ALRC-STM-002-2011
January 27, 2011
A Statement by the Asian Legal Resource Centre
NEPAL: Nepal urged to accept and implement UPR recommendations and end impunity
(Hong Kong, January 27, 2011)

On Tuesday, Nepal's human rights record was reviewed for the first time under the United Nations (UN) Human Rights Council’s Universal Periodic Review (UPR). The UPR process was established by the UN General Assembly on 15 March 2006 through resolution 60/251 to "review the fulfilment by each State of its human rights obligations and commitments." The procedure assessed Nepal's compliance with its international obligations to protect and promote human rights.

The UPR review, which represents an important opportunity to scrutinize the challenges Nepal faces in upholding human rights and strengthening its rule of law framework, was conducted on the basis of three reports: a report by the government of Nepal; a report by the UN’s Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) comprising information and recommendations by United Nations mechanisms and experts; and a report compiled by the OHCHR summarising the input by other stakeholders, including civil society organisation and the National Human Rights Commission.

The ALRC welcomes the dialogue held, notably the many questions raised by States concerning key issues such as torture, forced disappearances, gender- and caste-based discrimination, human rights defenders, freedom of expression, weakness of national institutions and legislation, and the overarching problem of impunity. The Government of Nepal now has the primary responsibility to implement the recommendations made as part of the review. As part of the UPR process, the government will now decide which recommendations it accepts and those it only “notes.” The ALRC strongly urges the government to accept and implement the recommendations made concerning these key issues, if its approach to human rights is to have any credibility.

During the review, the government of Nepal declared its full commitment to "establishing constitutional supremacy, ensuring the rule of law, good governance and human rights and guaranteeing the fundamental rights enshrined in the constitution of Nepal.” It added that, “Addressing impunity entails two aspects: addressing the past and maintaining the rule of law at present. The government is fully committed to work on both fronts." The ALRC welcomes the government of Nepal's commitment to tackle impunity and expects that this commitment will be followed by concrete steps in line with the recommendations made during the course of the review and international human rights laws and standards. The ALRC cautions that similar commitments have been made in the past by the Government of Nepal, but have remained unfulfilled to date. It must be noted that the ALRC is seriously concerned by the Nepalese delegation’s apparent reluctance to acknowledge some human rights violations during the UPR review, as will be seen below.

The ALRC and Nepalese NGO Advocacy Forum submitted a joint report to the UPR on 5 July 2010, which can be found here, along with a background document found here. The report focused on the impunity which persists for conflict-related and ongoing abuses, which have not been effectively investigated or prosecuted, as well as on the failure of the institutions of the rule of law to protect Nepal’s citizens. The report recommended that addressing the problem of impunity should be the prime focus of the UPR and action by the government of Nepal. It pointed to the institutional weaknesses of the judicial system, the lack of criminalization of certain human rights abuses such as torture, enforced disappearances and caste-based discrimination, as well as the absence of the right to effective remedy, which, together, greatly hamper the realization of the fundamental rights enshrined in the 2007 Interim Constitution. The report urged the Working Group on the UPR to consider as a priority under the UPR, issues such as the breakdown of the rule of law and the increased insecurity in the Terai region, forced disappearances, endemic torture, extra-judicial killings by security forces, persisting caste-based discrimination, gender-based violence, the vulnerable situation of human rights defenders, and the inability of the State to respond to such abuses.

During the review, questions and recommendations raised by a number of governments during the three-hour long UPR session reflected many of these concerns. The ALRC welcomes this and urges the Government of Nepal to accept the urgent need for it to address these serious issues and take appropriate action as a result.

Concerns about persisting impunity for past and ongoing abuses was repeatedly raised by delegations, including those from Japan, Czech Republic, Sweden, South Korea, France, Germany, the United Kingdom, Norway, Hungary, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Denmark and Switzerland. In questions submitted in advance to the government of Nepal, France had, for instance, said that it was "deeply preoccupied by the persistence of impunity enjoyed by the alleged perpetrators of numerous grave human rights violations committed during and since the conflict," and recommended during the session that, "the decisions of the judiciary taken in this respect should be fully respected by all institutional actors especially the army and the police forces". Norway recalled that addressing impunity is fundamental to foster peace, democracy and stability. In questions in advance, the Czech Republic stated that "failure to act on human rights abuses undermines respect for the rule of law" and Canada underlined that "addressing abuses committed by all sides during the decade long conflict and post conflict period in Nepal is an important element of transitional justice".

Several States, such as France, Spain, the UK and the United States, inquired about progress in establishing the transitional justice mechanisms included in the Comprehensive Peace Accord, namely the Truth and Reconciliation Commission and the Commission on Inquiry into Disappearances, and called for the criminalization of enforced disappearances. Norway inquired about measures to protect the police and justice system from political interference and to ensure that suspects accused of serious human rights abuses during the conflict are handed over to the police for proper investigation.

The need to strengthen the National Human Rights Commission as an independent and autonomous human rights body and to implement its recommendations was noted by several delegations, including Canada, the United States, France, India and Norway.

Allegations of misconduct by law enforcement authorities, qualified as "disturbing" by Japan, have also been a serious concern. The issue of the systematic use of torture was raised and the government was asked by several countries about its intention to introduce legislation to criminalize torture in line with international standards. Several delegations called for the effective investigations into all allegations of torture. Furthermore, several States expressed their concerns about allegations of extrajudicial killings in the Tarai and asked what measures were being taken to investigate them and to implement the recommendations of the OHCHR to establish an external oversight mechanism to investigate allegations of human rights abuses by security forces. In questions submitted in advance, the Danish delegation underlined the fact that "credible investigation of alleged human rights violations of security forces is an important part of strengthening the rule of law". The Czech Republic also urged the authorities to "support and protect witnesses as well as victims and their family members" in the investigation of allegations of human rights violations.

The persistence of gender- and caste-based violence and discrimination at all levels of Nepali society were also raised several times and the government was requested to explain what actions it is taking to address these problems, including with regard to: the levels of implementation of the Caste-based Discrimination and Untouchability Crime Elimination and Punishment Act and the National Dalit Rights Commission Bill; the investigation of allegations of caste-based discrimination; and the strengthening of the National Women's Commission and National Dalit Commission.

Obstacles to the freedom to speech, the vulnerability of journalists to threats, attacks and harassment, as well as the precarious situation of human rights defenders, were also repeatedly raised during the review. The Czech Republic, the United Kingdom, Norway, France and the United States asked for improved protection of human rights defenders and journalists through the launching of proper and impartial investigations of all allegations of threats and harassment against them.

These issues have been at the centre of the concerns of the civil society in Nepal for a long time. They all deeply impact the democratisation and peace process in the country. Now that they have been raised in the international arena as part of the UPR, it is the Government of Nepal's responsibility toward its citizens and the international community to respond by properly addressing these issues.

Of grave concern has been the government of Nepal’s denial of the reality of human rights abuses during the review. For example, one of the government delegates asserted that there is no systematic torture in Nepal and that "there are sufficient constitutional and legal safeguards for the prevention of torture in Nepal.” Independent international and national experts and observers have documented that the opposite is true: torture is still used as a common tool by the police as part of interrogation procedures, while the lack of legislation enabling the criminal prosecution of alleged perpetrators of torture has engendered systemic impunity concerning this grave violation of rights. Similarly, the ALRC is seriously concerned by the government's reluctance to acknowledge the existence of human rights violations committed by the security agencies, including the Nepal Army, which it claimed during the review was a "source of Nepali democracy". The delegation to the UPR stated that that there was already a "zero tolerance" policy toward "isolated" human rights violations committed by the security agencies. This is a complete denial of the reality on the ground, where not a single perpetrator of serious human rights violations committed during and since the conflict has faced prosecution. The government delegation also kept silent over other crucial issues, such as the need to protect the work of human rights defenders and the freedom of expression of journalists.

The Asian Legal Resource Centre therefore urges the Government of Nepal to acknowledge the reality of these persistent abuses and recognize its responsibility in addressing them. The Government is urged to accept the recommendations made concerning the issues highlighted above and commit to take measures to implement them in good faith and in a prompt, transparent and verifiable way.
# # #

About the ALRC: The Asian Legal Resource Centre is an independent regional non-governmental organisation holding general consultative status with the Economic and Social Council of the United Nations. It is the sister organisation of the Asian Human Rights Commission. The Hong Kong-based group seeks to strengthen and encourage positive action on legal and human rights issues at the local and national levels throughout Asia.

Wednesday, January 26, 2011

Nepal grilled on human rights issues in Geneva


Delegates from nearly 50 countries from around the world grilled Nepali officials in Geneva on Tuesday and expressed their concerns regarding what they said the overall situation of impunity in the country.
A glimpse of the Universal Periodic Review (UPR) session of Nepal.
“The international community has come together during Tuesday’s Universal Periodic Review (UPR) of Nepal to highlight growing concerns about impunity in the country and call for the government to address the worrying situation,” said Oliver Spencer, advocacy officer at the ARTICLE 19, a London-based group advocating freedom of expression. “Impunity was by far the most repeated issue during the Review and many delegations referred to continuous attacks against media workers and human rights defenders in Nepal.”
The delegations of the Czech Republic, Canada, France and US each recommended the government of Nepal specifically safeguard the security of journalists and implement adequate measures for the protection and investigation of crimes against journalists and human rights defenders.
The Czech Republic called for the proper investigation and prosecution in the precedent creating case of the killing of female reporter Uma Singh in 2009. Norway also recommended the government investigate attacks against women journalists and prosecute the perpetrators.
France urged the government address the difficulties in enforcing the rights to freedom of expression, assembly and information, in line with the recommendations made by the UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) stakeholders report, to which ARTICLE 19 contributed.
The issue of impunity was also raised by the delegations from Denmark, Germany, Hungary, Japan, Netherlands, New Zealand, South Korea, Switzerland and the UK.
The UK and Denmark recommended that the government of Nepal tackle impunity by creating an independent police commission responsible for all transfers and promotions, in order to end political interference in police duties through the threat of demotion or quick transfer. Delegations from Cambodia, the Maldives, Italy and Chile urged the government to invite all Special Mandates to Nepal on a regular basis.
In response, the government of Nepal pledged to tackle impunity and address the human rights concerns of delegates. The government was unwilling to accept the role of the Nepali Army in the continuation of widespread impunity, such as their protection of army personnel indicted by Nepali courts, arguing that the Nepali Army are fully supportive of human rights and any issues are not supported by policy.
The Nepal delegation is being led by Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Sujata Koirala. nepalnews.com


http://www.nepalnews.com/archive/2011/jan/jan26/news01.php

Monday, January 24, 2011

"Emergency Measure No. 1 Is Unconstitutional"


[경향신문] 2010년 12월 17일(금) 오후 01:57
가  가| 이메일| 프린트
Unanimous Supreme Court verdict: "violation of the essence of democracy"
'Yusin government' invoked it groundlessly ... All previous rulings based on Emergency Measure's constitutionality rejected

The Supreme Court of South Korea has ruled that emergency measures issued by former president Park Chung-hee have been in violation of the constitution.

The presidential Emergency Measures number nine in total and these were based on Article 53 of former president Park's Yusin Constitution of 1972. The Yusin government of the late President Park used the Emergency Measures, which were legally enforceable, to suspend the freedom and rights of the people and reinforce his military dictatorship.

On December 16, the Grand Bench of the Supreme Court, presided over by Justice Cha Han-sung, unanimously delivered "a not guilty verdict" at the retrial of O Jong-sang, who was convicted in 1975 of violating the Anticommunist Law and an Emergency Measure by the Supreme Court. Proclaiming Mr. O not guilty of violating the Emergency Measure, the Supreme Court stated as its reason the fact that Emergency Measure No. 1 was unconstitutional.

The Supreme Court gave two reasons to explain why the Emergency Measure violated the constitution. Firstly, it judged that although the measure was based on Article 53 of the Yusin Constitution, it violated the essence of democracy and was therefore unconstitutional. The court stated that "Emergency Measure No. 1 seriously restricted freedom of expression and personal liberty, which are essential elements of democracy, thereby violating basic rights that were guaranteed even by the Yusin Constitution."

It also judged that the measure did not satisfy the grounds for issuance specified in Article 53 of the Yusin Constitution, saying that "The Emergency Measure was (groundlessly) invoked, despite the fact that the state was not facing a serious crisis or under a direct security threat at the time."

The Supreme Court's verdict of unconstitutionality means that all existing judicial precedents have lost their legal validity. The court stated that it repealed all its verdicts passed since 1975 which were based on Emergency Measure No. 1 being constitutional.

Starting in 1975, the Supreme Court delivered guilty and not guilty verdicts with the view that Emergency Measure No. 1 was constitutional. Then, from the beginning of the 2000s, applications were made for retrial of cases of forced indictments and were accepted by courts.

Retrials began in lower courts, but cases were dismissed because the Emergency Measure no longer existed. Case dismissals, rather than not guilty verdicts, made it hard to receive criminal indemnity and impossible to receive damages from the state.

The Supreme Court stated, "This is highly significant in terms of judicial history, as it repeals the Supreme Court's judgment that Emergency Measure No. 1 was constitutional under the Yusin Constitution." Commenting on the verdict, the group MINBYUN Lawyers for a Democratic Society said, "This judgment corrects past mistakes where courts made rulings incompatible with the constitution and with justice."

In 1974, Mr. O was sentenced to three years in prison and three years' suspension of qualification after saying on a bus, "the government encourages people to eat flour-based foods, but high officials and rich people eat wheat-based food that consists mostly of eggs and meat, with just a few noodles. How can the people adapt to the government's policy?"

In 2007, however, the Truth and Reconciliation Commission recommended that Mr. O's case be retried, saying that he must be given an opportunity to restore his honor. A court also decided that his case must be retried. Seoul High Court last year declared Mr. O not guilty of violating the Anticommunist Law, but dismissed the part of his case related to the Emergency Measure.

Q: Emergency Measures?
A: A series of nine Emergency Measures passed by President Park Chung-hee in accordance with Article 53 of the Yusin Constitution of 1972. Emergency Measure No. 1, passed on January 8, 1974, banned denial of, opposition to, distortion of and maligning of the constitution, as well as the suggestion or instigation of such acts or telling others about them. It was criticized as a violent measure to suppress criticism of the Yusin system, and did in fact produce many innocent victims. (General news. Dec 17, 2010)
- ⓒ 경향신문 & 경향닷컴(www.khan.co.kr), 무단전재 및 재배포 금지〈경향닷컴은 한국온라인신문협회(www.kona.or.kr)의 디지털뉴스이용규칙에 따른 저작권을 행사합니다.〉 

Politician acquitted decades after execution


By North Asia correspondent Mark Willacy

Posted Fri Jan 21, 2011 12:32pm AEDT
A South Korean court has acquitted a former presidential candidate of subversion, half a century after he was executed.
Cho Bong-am was hanged 52 years ago on charges of trying to overthrow South Korea's government in collusion with the communist North.
The leader of the left-leaning Progressive Party remarked that if he had committed a wrong, it was entering politics in the first place.
Mr Cho's case was reopened by South Korea's truth and reconciliation commission and the supreme court has now unanimously cleared him, calling his execution a violation of the principles of a free democracy.
His family says it can now engrave his tombstone which has been kept blank all these years while they waited for his acquittal.
Cho Bong-am unjustly executed: Supreme Court
January 21, 2011
Cho Bong-am
The Supreme Court yesterday vindicated independence activist and politician Cho Bong-am by overruling a death sentence handed down 52 years ago for breaking the National Security Law. Cho was hung for the crime on July 31, 1959.

In its ruling, the Court said Cho played a crucial role in shaping Korea’s progressive politics.

“The Jinbo [Progress] Party [founded by Cho] cannot be viewed as a denial of free democracy or a violation of the basic order of democracy,” the Supreme Court ruled yesterday afternoon. “It also cannot be seen as a political party established to overthrow the nation.”

The Truth and Reconciliation Commission reviewed Cho’s case at the request of his 83-year-old daughter Cho Ho-jeong, and called for a retrial in 2007 to clear his name.

Cho, born to a peasant family in Ganghwa Island of Incheon in 1898, had a tumultuous life, living through Japanese colonization, the Korean War and finally challenging Korea’s first president, the autocratic Syngman Rhee.

Cho served his first prison term on charges of participating in the March 1, 1919, Independence Movement, and he was active in the independence movement against Japanese rule.

After entering politics as a lawmaker in 1948, he served as Korea’s first agriculture minister and was appointed vice speaker of the National Assembly in 1950.

Cho ran for the presidency against Rhee in 1952 and 1956. In the second election he received 30 percent of the vote, which worried Rhee.

In November 1956, he formed the Jinbo (Progress) Party, which led to his arrest in January 1958 on allegations of being a communist sympathizer, violating the National Security Law.

Cho was investigated by Korean special military forces for two months. The military additionally charged him with espionage based on testimony from a military official surnamed Yang who worked in the government’s military espionage bureau, claiming he had information that Cho started the Jinbo Party on orders from and with funding from North Korea.

Cho was sentenced to five years in jail at his first trial but was sentenced to death in two subsequent trials.

He appealed for a retrial, but his request was rejected and Cho was hung 18 hours later.

Before being executed, Cho said, “The only sin I have committed is that I have initiated a political movement that campaigned for a society in which a lot of people equally live well. I hope my death doesn’t come in vain and will serve as development of this country’s democracy.”

In yesterday’s ruling, the Supreme Court overruled Cho’s espionage conviction as well.

“Military special forces don’t have the right to investigate an individual, but Cho was taken to the force for questioning without a warrant,” the Court said. “It’s also hard to credit the testimony [of Yang] because it can’t be seen as a verified testimony.”

In regard to charges that he possessed ammunition and a gun, the Supreme Court suspended the charges saying Cho was “an independence activist and Korea’s first agriculture minister, who built a foundation for Korea’s economy.”

Cho’s daughter hailed the Court’s ruling, though she said it took her family over five decades to restore her father’s reputation.

“I lived a hard life over 50 years [after my father’s death], and I’m relieved I can see my father after I die,” Cho Ho-jeong said in a press briefing. “I should engrave an inscription on my father’s tomb. I haven’t engraved an inscription yet because I wanted to do it after he was vindicated. Killing a political opponent in this way should be noted so it won’t be repeated.”

An official at the Supreme Court said the ruling was significant in that it will spark a revaluation of liberal politicians and activists of the Jinbo Party, who were tortured and branded as pro-North Korean activists.

“Cho’s case is regarded as Korea’s first judicial murder, but to a large extent, he was a victim of the Cold War,” the official said.


By Kim Mi-ju [mijukim@joongang.co.kr]

http://joongangdaily.joins.com/article/view.asp?aid=2931306

 01-20-2011 20:43   
Cho Bong-am cleared of spy charge in 52 years

Cho Bong-am
By Kim Tae-jong

The Supreme Court Thursday overturned a guilty verdict on the late Cho Bong-am (1898-1959), 52 years after the nation’s first progressive party leader was executed on charges of espionage by the government of then-President Syngman Rhee.

Cho, who created the Jinbo (progressive) Party in 1956, challenged President Rhee in a presidential election and was executed three years later for espionage charges.

The retrial came after the Truth and Reconciliation Commission concluded in September, 2007 that the original trial was clouded in mystery and the case should be retried.

Cho has been viewed as the victim of a “judicial murder.” It also said the subversion charge against him was created by the Rhee administration to “get rid of Rhee’s strongest rival in the presidential election.”

Upon the request, the Supreme Court finally held a hearing on Cho’s death last year to determine a second ruling on whether Cho’s execution was legally justifiable and decided to hold a retrial for Cho.

On Jan. 13, 1958, Cho was arrested by police on charges of spying and violating the National Security Law. He was charged with being sympathetic with North Korea’s reunification policy and receiving funds from the North.

He was initially sentenced to a five-year jail term at a district court. But both the appellate court and the Supreme Court sentenced him to death on Feb. 27, 1959, rejecting the call for a retrial from his family, claiming the espionage charges were concocted using faulty evidence and manipulated testimonies.
e3dward@koreatimes.co.kr

http://www.koreatimes.co.kr/www/news/nation/2011/01/113_80056.html